Monday, June 24, 2019

Ewa Field History Project - Battle of Midway


Ewa Field History Project   P.O. Box 75578   Kapolei, Hawaii 96707
  

Aloha,

In an important historic review of Ewa Field, MCAS Ewa and Pacific war history- particularly the June 1942 Battle of Midway and other early 1942 Pacific actions, reveals the largely unrecognized operational and supporting role of Ewa Field in 1942. Many naval aviation histories and archives have incorrectly assigned this history to NAS Barbers Point and various early aircraft carrier air group histories based in Hawaii during that period. 

The 1941 Ewa Field, approximately 180 acres, was placed on the Hawaii state register in 2015 and on the NPS National Register in 2016. However the period of historic significance was only recognized for December 7, 1941 to December 30, 1941, which was the attack on Pearl Harbor and the subsequent Japanese naval activity around Oahu and on Wake Island, which fell on December 23, 1941.

At that point in time, the very early construction of NAS Barbers Point had begun, which was expected to take about one year to complete. However, with the major threat that the Imperial Japanese Navy presented to Hawaii at that time, a decision was made to direct all money, material and labor forces available from NAS Barbers Point to the adjacent Ewa Field, which had just become fully operational.

Because Ewa Field was already a Navy airfield, designated as a major airship mooring mast (1925 -1940) the January 1941 arrival of Marine Corp aviation was considered as an advance expeditionary force that would move further out into the Pacific (Wake, Midway, etc.) And in fact this was why Ewa Field was minus many planes on December 7, 1941, because air units had been deployed to Wake and Midway. This Marine aircraft movement by the USS Enterprise was in fact the primary reason it was not in Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941. That and a subsequent Pacific storm that both delayed the Enterprise arrival to Pearl Harbor by a matter of hours as well as helping to mask the large Japanese force approaching Oahu from the northwest.

In the early hectic days of 1942 Ewa Field, located in southwest Oahu suddenly became the Hawaiian Islands main frontline combat airfield. The very rapid expansion of Ewa Field for two Navy carrier groups lead to the Navy largely taking over the base once two major new aircraft parking ramps had been constructed and the runway lengthened. In fact the Navy began referring to Ewa Field as Naval Air Station Ewa (NAS Ewa). Confusing the historic records, archive documents and photo collections further was also the general assignment of Ewa Field as NAS Barbers Point. Many records still even state that NAS Barbers Point was where 1942 carrier air groups in the Pacific based and flew to the Pacific battles of Coral Sea and Midway. But this was not possible from the still under construction NAS Barbers Point.

Included with this blog letter are links to command histories and air photos that help make the case as to why there needs to be a history review and new analysis. It is also very important right now because a great deal of the early 1942 Ewa Field, later designated Marine Corps Air Station Ewa, still exists in a WW-II condition and largely undeveloped. The area was greatly fortified with anti-aircraft gun batteries, bunkers, concrete aircraft revetments and fuel storage areas. 

Historians and researchers began preparing in 2018 a National Register nomination of one of the largely unknown key aspects of the Battle of Midway – the 1942 Ewa Field aircraft revetments where many of the Navy and Marine planes left in late May 1942 to participate in the incredible and now legendary WW-II Pacific battle. Ewa Field was the key supporting airfield where all of the Marine aircraft originated from that participated in the Midway battle, as well as the Navy air groups from USS Hornet, which included Torpedo Squadron 8. We now know other carrier air groups, such as USS Enterprise were also directly connected with Ewa Field. The Pearl Harbor Ford Island Naval Air Station sent to Ewa Field CASU 1 (Carrier Aircraft Service Unit) to maintain the carrier aircraft and which was later spun off as CASU 2.

How and why Ewa Field was largely denied its important historic place as America’s 1942 “Battle for Hawaii” (i.e. Battle of Britain) key frontline combat airfield recognition and and role in the June 1942 Battle of Midway is because of the way base command histories and air group carrier histories were recorded in early 1942. Local Hawaii histories of early 1942 present a picture of great fear and almost panic in the Islands after the December 7, 1941 Japanese air attack. Martial Law was declared, tanks rolled through the streets, sandbag machine gun positions and air raid bunkers were installed everywhere with gas masks required of every citizen, school child and even babies.

Expecting a Japanese invasion, nighttime gunfire and reports of parachute landings were common as many soldiers, Marines and airmen carried loaded weapons everywhere, including to Waikiki Beach. News of Singapore, Hong Kong, the Philippines and Wake Island falling to Japanese military forces spooked everyone in Hawaii. Very early in 1942 the new Pacific commander Admiral Chester Nimitz ordered a complete realignment of PNAB (Pacific Naval Air Base) construction priorities, including a massive expansion of Ewa Field runways, ramp spaces, air defenses and fortifications. Money, manpower and materials intended for a just beginning construction of NAS Barbers Point was all redirected to Ewa Field.

As a local historian that has been fortunate to have had many good sources for military histories, I have spent the past seven years researching newly discovered Ewa Field photos and documents from archives and the largely overlooked role Ewa Field played in post Pearl Harbor, early 1942 wartime history. In what seemed like an impossible goal due to very extensive land developer pressures and politics, the 175-180 acres of former 1941 Navy and Marine Corps Ewa airfield, where US Marines died in battle, was placed on the NPS National Historic register in May, 2016.

Now as there has been continued further historic research into the largely unrecognized 1942 Pacific War history of Ewa Field and its relationship to early key Pacific battles, the still existing 75 concrete "clam shell" aircraft revetments have become a very important visual reminder of why they were constructed for NAS Ewa Field Navy aircraft. Revealing more than we expected were the even earlier and still existing sandbag and concrete gunite revetments where specific Marine Corps Brewster Buffalo planes that flew in the Battle of Midway were parked. As we went through more archives we discovered new historic airbase documents, diagrams and photos connected with the early 1942 planes, pilots and squadrons based at NAS Ewa Field.

Also many brief mentions in numerous recent Pacific war books indicated more undeveloped Ewa Field stories and links to famous Navy and Marine pilots, squadrons and early combat planes. The names and notations of well-preserved air group squadron pilots and crews were found penciled and painted on Ewa Field aircraft revetment concrete walls. Archive photos never previously well identified lead to the documentation of post attack sandbag revetment sites, machine gun positions, ammunition bunkers and Army anti-aircraft gun battery sites, all indicating a great need for further research and documentation of the many largely unsurveyed historic archeology sites at Ewa Field and MCAS Ewa.

Further, we have since found Ewa Field connections with nearly every major combat action in the Pacific, including of course Wake Island, but also the April 1942 Doolittle Raid, May 1942 Battle of Coral Sea, June 1942 Battle of Midway and the 1942-43 Guadalcanal Henderson Field Cactus Air Force which was MCAS Ewa Field’s direct airfield off spring. Once Henderson Field and NAS Barbers Point became operational MCAS Ewa, established in September 1942, became the logistical and training hub for Marine Corp aviation in the Pacific. MCAS Ewa continued to expand greatly to the end of the war and afterwards continued support of the post war China Marines and even provided R5D (Douglas C-54) transport aircraft and pilots for the 1949 Berlin Airlift. 

At the successful conclusion of the Cold War the MCAS Ewa air wing command was inactivated and the base went through a base realignment and closure process that ended in 1952 and its absorption into NAS Barbers Point. The Marines transferred aircraft over to the newly recommissioned MCAS Kaneohe which had formerly been NAS Kaneohe. In further musical chairs the Navy's Patrol Wing Two command, which had their PBY's shot to pieces in December 7, 1941, moved to NAS Barbers Point. The former MCAS Ewa Field was in 1958 made Patrol Wing Two's headquarters with construction of a new headquarters building (facility 972) by the old Ewa Field front gate which had been strafed by Zero fighters on December 7, 1941.

The Navy 1960 mission changed from the Pacific Barrier Squadron (AEWBARRONPAC -Airborne Early Warning Barrier Squadron Pacific) flying Lockheed WV-2 (EC-121K) to the new reconnaissance and anti-submarine warfare missions with Lockheed P-3 Orion aircraft. An ASWOC (Anti Submarine Warfare Operations Center) was added to the Patrol Wing Two headquarters facility building 972 and a new SOSUS (Sound Surveillance facility for tracking Soviet submarines) was built next door with two large circular antenna arrays, satellite dish and microwave link to Pearl Harbor. In 1999 Patrol Wing Two moved back to Kaneohe as NAS Barbers Point was closed under congressional BRAC. This is also why MCAS Ewa was forgotten and widely thought of as just NAS Barbers Point. The Cold War had been won and both bases began fading into history.

Most importantly I believe this new review of Pacific War history records is long overdue and especially in light of the fact that many Americans are losing their understanding of the important personal sacrifices that were made in early 1942 when the outcome of the war was not at all certain.

Also many of the very important Pacific War battle sites – Wake Island, Coral Sea, Midway Island, are not easily accessible places for most Americans. 1942 Ewa Field is the closest historic bullet marked and airfield link to these early Pacific battles that are often very different from other later 1943-44 Pacific island invasion battlefields. It was a very different war in early 1942 and Japan could have well advanced further taking Hawaii if the Battle of Midway had seen US Navy carriers sunk instead of four Imperial Japanese carriers.

And many of the lost at sea remains of those who paid the ultimate price in these Pacific sea battles have no dedicated memorial site, such as 1941 Pearl Harbor has, visited by millions every year. In fact surprisingly Ewa Field, Wake Island and Midway Island are not part of the National Park Service World War II Valor in the Pacific National Monument (recently now changed to NPS Pearl Harbor National Memorial.) No other Hawaii location has still existing WW-II runways and revetments like Ewa Field that are as closely historically linked to these incredible early 1942 air battle histories. Most other Oahu battlefield sites are on still active military bases and are far less accessible and visually recognizable as authentic Pacific WW-II era.

I believe the Ewa Field aircraft revetments placed on the National Register of Historic Places and making former MCAS Ewa Field a WW-II National Pacific Battlefield memorial monument will provide an important new still existing reference for future visitors of what transpired at those early 1942 Pacific battlefields.

Sincerely,

John Bond, Director
Ewa Field History Project
P.O. Box 75578
Kapolei, HI 96707



***********************************************************************

"Remembering our solemn commitment to their memory is the promise
that is fulfilled at battlegrounds that are preserved and enshrined by
our nation."


Daniel A. Martinez, Chief Historian
WWII Valor in the Pacific National Monument

Medal of Honor recipients honored at Ewa Field

Tuesday, June 18, 2019

Real History of Ewa Field - Battle of Midway


Real History of Ewa Field - Battle of Midway


From John Bond
Ewa Battlefield historian
2017-08-18

Attached is an introductory letter and attached information being sent to request possible information, photos or documentation about 1942 Naval aviation history, Battle of Coral Sea, Midway, etc. that can help document a National Register nomination of aircraft revetments at former MCAS Ewa Field.

One of the major findings is that many histories and archives are wrongly attributing operations to Naval Air Station Barbers Point because of mistaken command histories confusing the two different Hawaii airfields in 1942 and their periods of operation.

A review of many books published about this period often correctly attribute Ewa Field as a naval air group base but many archives and museums are not because of the way command histories were later misinterpreted confusing the two airfields.




Tuesday, December 30, 2014

Royal Navy Mapped 1825 Malden Trail On University of Hawaii West Oahu Campus

Royal Navy Mapped 1825 Malden Trail On University of Hawaii West Oahu Campus

By John Bond

The 1825 Malden Trails would be a really great visitor attraction with likely state and federal 
funding, as well as serve as a walking and bicycle path across the Ewa Plain from Fort Weaver 
Road to the campus of UH West Oahu and then on through Kapolei and the Leeward coast. It 
would be an historic, cultural and environmental preservation win-win for everyone...but right 
now they are on the verge of being bulldozed unless action isn't taken immediately!


The 1825 Malden Trails, mapped during an expedition of the British Royal Navy HMS Blonde to Oahu, showed the trail connections between various locations of native Hawaiian communities at the time of early Western contact.

Two routes of the trail run by the UH West Oahu campus which is located on former Ewa Sugar Plantation on the Ewa Plain. The plantation maintained a detailed sugar cane field map for many decades and fortunately most of the agricultural cane fields can still be seen from the air, especially using a GIS software tool like Google Earth.

Plotting the trail route was a matter of reviewing many older USGS maps and air photos taken by the US military that reveal where the oldest roads appeared. In reviewing the history of trails in the continental US, in most cases early trails were made by Indians migrating from place to place.

When Western settlers arrived trail scouts showed them the Indian trails to follow. Originally with ox drawn wagons, trails were improved for carriages, early automobiles, then becoming improved roads, etc.  

On the Ewa Plain there was one single land owner, James Campbell, who leased out the ancient coral reef plain to the Ewa Plantation Company. The plantation cane haul roads and railway network largely followed existing trail ways made by native Hawaiians. 

By overlaying the 1825 Malden Trails map, which was not made with the benefit of air photos or Google Earth, the best fit is made where the oldest main roads and plantation cane haul tracks appeared as the plantation expanded. They often ran side by side.

While not perfect, the 1825 Malden Trails shown below in a modern geographic context are the most likely ancient routes that could still be preserved as the traditional native Hawaiian rights of way under the Na Hele trail program. This should be done before it is too late. 

https://hawaiitrails.ehawaii.gov/info.php

The Honolulu City Council in 2012 passed a resolution to preserve the trails, but nothing was ever followed up. Land developers continue to bulldoze everything without any regard for cultural history and State law protecting these very important native Hawaiian trails.


Despite Hawaii State Law, Ancient Historic Ewa Plain Trails Being Destroyed By HART Rail Land Developers

http://honouliuli.blogspot.com/2014/12/ancient-historic-ewa-plain-trails.html


Above, the UH West Oahu campus with Ewa Plantation field numbers for reference.


The western trail ran from the village of Honouliuli to Kahe Point. A mauka trail branched off to Palehua. Over time trail roads were somewhat straightened out for cane railway and cane trucks.


The 1825 Malden Trails as overlaid on a 1939 Ewa Plantation field map.


UH West Oahu campus in relation to Ewa Sugar Plantation with main road and rail routes


Ewa Plantation and villages as seen from Makakilo. On the right side is MCAS Ewa Field


The Ewa Plantation maintained their own railway. The original Ewa hospital 
location is believed to be where the 1825 Malden Trails branched off to the 
makai shoreline communities of  Kualaka'i and One'ula. 


Ewa Plantation with some modern developments around the remaining agriculture fields. 


Another view of the 1825 Malden Trails with still remaining Ewa Plantation sugar fields.


The overall view of the 1825 mapped native Hawaiian trails on the entire Ewa Plain.


Area circled in red is the HART Rail Area of Potential Effect (APE).

HART Rail And The State of Hawaii Should Preserve the Historic Trails of the Ewa Plain


The Governor of Hawaii, The Hawaii State Legislature, The Mayor of Honolulu and the Honolulu City Council should absolutely and unequivocally follow state law and preserve the ancient historic native Hawaiian trails of the Ewa Plain as originally identified in the British Royal Navy surveyed map of Oahu published in 1825. A City Council resolution passed in 2012 urged the same initiative.



Honouliuli Ewa Plain Pueos


The Disappearing Sacred Guardians Of Native Lands On The Ewa Plain




The HMS Blonde played an important role in early Hawaiian history, see link:



Honolulu City Council RESOLUTION 12-172, CD1 (2012) passed unanimously:

URGING THE HAWAII COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND 
THE STATE OF HAWAII TO RECOGNIZE AND PRESERVE 
THE HISTORIC TRAILS OF THE EWA PLAINS.







Saturday, December 20, 2014

Remains of December 7, 1941 Japanese Crash Lie Beneath Ewa Beach Golf Course

Stars and Stripes Logo

Remains of December 7, 1941 Japanese Crash Lie Beneath Ewa Beach Golf Course

Stars and Stripes  December 4, 2014


FORT SHAFTER, Hawaii — A local historian is convinced he’s located the site where a two-man Japanese dive-bomber crew crashed on the morning of Dec. 7, 1941, and was buried nearby: the tony grounds of Hoakalei Country Club Golf Course in Ewa Beach.

“The responsible thing to do is at least make an attempt to find these guys,” said John Bond, a semi-retired Ewa resident who has labored for years to bring recognition to the largely forgotten Marine Corps Air Station Ewa and its role in the 1941 battle. “If they can’t find them, then put up a marker saying this is a crash site and remember that so-and-so was killed here. I don’t understand why that would be a problem.”

But the golf course’s owner, Haseko Development, has been less than receptive to the idea of an active search for the grave on the property, which the company announced in October was being sold to a Japanese firm. Haseko Vice President Sharene Saito Tam said the company has done all it was required to do in identifying culturally and archaeologically significant artifacts on the property during development and has found no evidence of such a grave. Further, she said, Bond does not have documentation that pinpoints the gravesite’s exact location.

As to placing a marker on the grounds, she said: “From the company’s point of view, if there was evidence that showed that to be the case, of course it would be considered, but at this point there is nothing like that. But to ask any landowner to put a marker that indicates a grave where you don’t know a grave exists does not seem appropriate or respectful of the people they are trying to name there.”

Of the roughly 60 Japanese troops who were killed or lost during the Dec. 7 attack, many were buried in various cemeteries on Oahu but were repatriated after the war. About 30 Japanese remain missing from that day.

One notable memorial to a Japanese airman stands in Marine Corps Base Hawaii in Kaneohe Bay on Oahu. A bronze plaque marks the spot where Lt. Fusata Iita, commander of the 3rd Aircraft Group of the Japanese Imperial Navy, crashed his plane on a hillside near Kansas Tower that morning. Iita’s body was long ago returned to Japan.

The defense attache with the Japan consulate in Honolulu said the case of the two Ewa airmen is “a difficult situation” for Japan because the site is private property and the owner says there’s no evidence to back up Bond’s assertion.

During the past few years, Bond and a group of historians specializing in the 1941 attack have gathered extensive documentation and photos about the crash site, which had been lost to time and land development.

Even Tom Dye, the archaeologist contracted by Haseko to monitor its land development, admitted that Bond and his colleagues have “done an incredible amount of work” in tracking down photos and accounts of the crash.

“They’ve found much more than I think anybody could have expected about this crash event,” Dye said. “But there’s just nothing yet that gets us a location that we could narrow things down and really make a concerted effort to look for a burial.”

Comparing old photographs and military reports from the time of the attack, Bond said he has calculated the crash site lies within a 50-yard radius of the golf course’s club house.

A Dec. 9, 1941, report by Capt. Lester Milz, with the 251st Coastal Artillery, noted that the badly burned bodies of two Japanese crewmen had been found and his men disposed of the remains. Two days a later, an Army staff officer visited Milz’s battery and wrote in his diary that he’d been told the airmen’s bodies had been buried in a “coral grave.”

“I knew they buried them in a sinkhole because that’s what we have out here,” Bond said of Ewa Plain, which is an ancient limestone field. “You don’t dig easily in this ground. It’s like concrete.”

Bond contends that burying bodies beside crash sites was common in that era.

“If you had a crash and couldn’t extract the people out, you just buried them by the plane,” he said.

Dye said that even if the exact crash site is pinpointed, there’s no direct evidence indicating where the bodies were buried.

“You really just have to guess at that point,” Dye said. “Mr. Bond perhaps is comfortable with guessing, but you’re not supposed to guess. We really don’t have any credible evidence to lead us to a place where we could productively search for remains of the two airmen.”

Bond suggested that ground-penetrating sonar could be used to detect the grave.

“GPR has highly evolved in the last few years,” he said. “They’ve used it on archaeological sites to find tombs. It will detect these sinkholes. It’s also used in old cemeteries.”

Dye, however, said that limestone subsurface is “a nightmare scenario for ground-penetrating sonar.”

“The problem you have with ground-penetrating radar is there are just a huge number of false positives,” Dye said. “You’d have to dig every single one of them up to find out what they were. It’s not specific enough to tell you, oh, that’s bone versus that’s a rock or that’s a root.”

Bond has written a request to the Joint POW/MIA Accounting Command, which is tasked with locating and retrieving the remains of U.S. servicemembers lost overseas, requesting that it take an active role in searching for the grave.

“Getting involved in another nation’s recovery event is not something we’d typically do unless it was in the course of one of our own investigations,” JPAC spokesman Lee Tucker said. The agency has in the past provided research assistance to the Japan Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare’s Social Welfare and War Victims Bureau, which oversees such recoveries.

Tucker said the Japanese government did not require JPAC’s assistance or approval in searching for remains in Hawaii.

But Takeshi Ogino, the defense attache at the Japan consulate in Honolulu, said Japan did not have a comparable agency such as JPAC to research and retrieve MIA remains in foreign countries. He said the consulate had not received an “official request” from either Bond or the Haseko group in regard to searching for the airmen’s grave or commemorating the crash site.

Haseko’s Tam said that if Bond produces “additional information and evidence that we can authenticate,” the company might consider further search.

But Bond contends that the time to actively search and recover the remains is now, as the 73rd anniversary of the attack nears.

“If a decent search was done they could be found,” he said.

National Archives Photo Taken Dec 7 From B-17-E By Army Photographer Lee Embree


A US Navy SBD was also shot down and crashed at this same location as the D3A Val 
*************************************************************

‘Cadaver dog’ work more accepted by cops, courts


"Seeing is believing," says Mark Noah, the founder of History Flight, a nonprofit foundation whose mission includes finding the tens of thousands of fallen American veterans whose bodies were never recovered.

Buster and Dostie, working with a team of volunteers and paid staff members who also use ground-penetrating radar and historic records, have helped the organization unearth the remains of missing Americans lost in World War II battles in Europe and on the south Pacific island of Tarawa.

****************************************************************

WW II Japanese Air Crew Buried Under Ewa Beach Hawaii Golf Course



Tour of December 7, 1941 Ewa Field, US Navy SBD And Japanese Aichi Val Crash Sites
by John Bond, Ewa Battlefield historian


***********************************************************

MORE LINKS HERE:

One'ula Beach: The Ewa Location Of Historic December 7, 1941 Air Photos By Lee Embree From Army Boeing B-17 


Ewa Corridor- Most Important, Least Documented Aspect of Dec. 7, 1941 Pearl Harbor Attack



Draft Ewa Plains Battlefield Nomination And Photo Archive Available


http://ewabattlefield.blogspot.com/2014/08/Ewa-Battlefield-Nomination.html